Turn your fall data into a plan

Start with a free 30-minute team review to name your priority students before winter break.

Start Your Fall Reset

Learning Entry 1: Culture Is What We Practice, Not What We Post

Relationships

Learning Entry 5:

Belief to Practice -
Staying in the Struggle

How leaders navigate competing beliefs and create the conditions for meaningful change

Dr. Morgan Goering · October 29, 2026 · 8-9 min read

When Two Schools Became One

When I first moved to Minnesota, I accepted an assistant director of student support services position as two school communities consolidated into one K–8 building. Although the elementary and middle school staff now occupied the same space, the shared systems necessary to function as one community had not yet been established.

My responsibilities included daily student support operations, schoolwide behavioral practices, and the cultural challenges of bringing two established communities together. It was my first year in charter school leadership, and the experience fundamentally changed how I understood organizational improvement.

I encountered an extraordinary commitment to doing whatever was necessary for students. I valued that dedication, but I also began questioning what happened when individual effort compensated for organizational systems that weren't sustainable.

That tension became especially visible in our approach to behavioral support.

When Support Means Different Things

Before consolidation, middle school educators had relied heavily on their dean to conduct initial behavioral conversations, remove students for additional support, and manage situations that might otherwise have been addressed through classroom-based practices.

When the dean became responsible for both school communities, those established expectations quickly exceeded the position's capacity. Elementary educators needed access to support, while middle school educators expected the familiar arrangement to continue.

We faced more than a staffing challenge. We had competing beliefs about what supporting students and educators should look like.

For middle school teachers, the dean represented predictability and professional support. Changing that arrangement during an already significant transition introduced uncertainty. From my perspective, we needed a sustainable system that strengthened classroom practices while preserving access to additional assistance.

I remember hearing familiar statements: We've always done it this way. We've already tried that.

At the time, I struggled to distinguish genuine disagreement from insufficient skills, concerns about new leadership, or anxiety associated with organizational change.

Looking back, I recognize that my interpretation needed greater empathy. I understood the systems problem but could have moved more deliberately through the experiences of the educators affected by it.

I was asking people to reconsider a practice that helped them feel supported before fully understanding what they believed they were losing.

When Our Practices Reveal Our Beliefs

Argyris and Schön (1978) distinguish between espoused theory, the principles people identify as guiding their actions, and theory-in-use, the principles reflected in their actual behavior. This distinction offers a useful perspective on our consolidation experience.

Both communities believed in supporting students. Yet our established practices reflected different assumptions about professional responsibility, behavioral intervention, and the distribution of organizational resources.

Our shared commitment had not become a shared operational understanding.

I now recognize that organizational beliefs are revealed not only through stated values but also through everyday decisions, established routines, and the allocation of support.

When those practices contradict our intentions, leadership requires more than identifying what others need to change. It requires examining the assumptions embedded in the systems we've created and our own responses to the people operating within them.

Implementation Requires More Than New Expectations

Our behavioral support challenge also required us to examine the research informing our practices.

The Center on PBIS identifies proactive classroom practices, explicit instruction, consistent responses, and clear procedures for addressing behavioral concerns as essential elements of Tier 1 support. These practices operate alongside systems for providing additional assistance when necessary (Center on PBIS, n.d.).

Strengthening classroom-based support, however, should not mean transferring responsibilities to educators without developing their capacity.

Fixsen and colleagues (2005) identify practitioner competencies, organizational supports, and leadership as essential considerations in implementation. Their work reinforces a distinction I have encountered repeatedly: selecting an evidence-based practice is not the same as establishing the conditions necessary to implement it.

In our situation, meaningful improvement required clarifying responsibilities, identifying professional learning needs, and preserving appropriate access to the dean. We needed to build a shared approach rather than simply redistribute the workload.

I now see how a supported pilot could have created space for that learning. We might have selected one classroom-based practice, modeled its implementation, established clear procedures for additional assistance, and examined educators' experiences before expanding the approach.

Change did not need to happen immediately. It needed to happen intentionally.

Staying in the Struggle

One of my most important leadership lessons from that year concerns how quickly our perceptions can influence difficult conversations.

When someone challenges a proposed change, we may interpret their response as unwillingness, insufficient skill, or conflicting beliefs. Yet the same response may reflect legitimate concerns about implementation, previous experiences, or uncertainty about losing familiar support.

Edmondson's (1999) research on psychological safety identifies the importance of interpersonal conditions that allow teams to acknowledge uncertainty, raise concerns, and engage in learning. Although her research examined organizational teams rather than schools specifically, it offers a useful perspective on the conditions leaders create during disagreement.

I increasingly understand that conflict is not necessarily evidence that improvement has stalled. It can reveal the assumptions, experiences, and organizational conditions that require our attention.

This does not eliminate the responsibility to establish expectations. Rather, it challenges leaders to maintain those expectations while remaining curious about the experiences influencing implementation.

Beliefs rarely change within our comfort zones. Leaders must be willing to remain engaged when conversations become difficult, including when those conversations challenge their own assumptions.

From Belief to Practice

If I were entering that building today, I would approach the transition differently.

I would begin by understanding what educators valued about the existing arrangement. I would distinguish the support they needed from the particular structure through which they had previously received it. Together, we could examine relevant research, identify a manageable alternative, and establish the coaching and organizational supports necessary to test it.

The Active Implementation Frameworks describe improvement cycles as opportunities to examine implementation, learn from evidence, and refine practices over time (National Implementation Research Network, 2016).

That process offers an alternative to expecting immediate agreement. It allows teams to establish a shared purpose while developing confidence through supported experience.

I cannot retrospectively claim that this approach would have resolved every challenge we encountered. What I understand now is that recognizing an organizational problem and preparing people to address it are different leadership responsibilities.

I entered that year believing strongly in integrity of practice and professional responsibility. Those beliefs remain unchanged. My understanding of how to translate them into sustainable organizational practices has continued to develop.

Belief becomes practice when leaders remain engaged long enough to transform disagreement into shared understanding, supported implementation, and collective learning.

A Belief-to-Practice Inquiry

Examine Ask Take one step
Beliefs What assumptions shape our current approach? Surface different perspectives.
Conditions What support does the existing practice provide? Identify benefits and limitations.
Capacity What does implementation require? Clarify skills, resources, and responsibilities.
Practice What alternative could we examine? Design one supported pilot.
Learning What are we discovering? Use evidence and feedback to refine the approach.

Reflect. Connect. Grow.

Reflect: When disagreement emerges, how might my initial interpretation limit what I learn?

Connect: Where do our established practices support some individuals while unintentionally constraining others?

Grow: Identify one recurring disagreement. Design a supported opportunity to examine an evidence-based alternative and learn from its implementation.

References

Argyris, C., & Schön, D. A. (1978). Organizational learning: A theory of action perspective. Addison-Wesley.

Center on PBIS. (n.d.). Tier 1; Classroom PBIS. https://www.pbis.org

Edmondson, A. (1999). Psychological safety and learning behavior in work teams. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), 350–383.

Fixsen, D. L., et al. (2005). Implementation research: A synthesis of the literature. University of South Florida.

National Implementation Research Network. (2016). Active implementation practice and science. University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.

Bring This Entry to

Your Team

Use the Belief-to-Practice Inquiry Protocol to help your team separate what you saw from what you assumed, then plan one supported change with Reflect. Connect. Grow. prompts.

Talk it through with us.

Bring us the work your team is carrying. If you want another perspective on a priority, challenge, or implementation question, we can help you think through what makes sense next.

Before You Go

Think about one idea from this entry that connects to the work in front of you.

What is one thing worth noticing, discussing, or doing differently because of it?

  • Reflect: What stood out to you in this entry?

  • Connect: Where do you see this showing up in your own team or system?

  • Grow: What is one next step worth trying, discussing, or revisiting?

Before You Go

Think about one idea from this entry that connects to the work in front of you.

What is one thing worth noticing, discussing, or doing differently because of it?

  • Reflect: What stood out to you in this entry?

  • Connect: Where do you see this showing up in your own team or system?

  • Grow: What is one next step worth trying, discussing, or revisiting?

A leadership and implementation ecosystem helping education leaders turn good ideas into change that lasts.

Stay in the Conversation

Get new playbooks, leadership tools, and district stories in your inbox.